As for the controversy part-
Fans have said that elle is being racist by portraying ash 2 shades lighter and whiter than she is. Honestly, fashion shoots are creative avenues and i dont understand the big deal. I am the first person to stand out against the whole fairness hype-i would rather bein the skin im in right now than be a pale ghost , but the shoot was obviously trying to channel the whole porcelain doll look of the Victorian Era – complete with flouncy layered Gowns by Rohit Bal. The same way you can argue thats not her natural hair- its coloured so you are not depicting the true colour of her hair either…Its a stupid controversy if you ask me, its the photoshoot directors creative liberty.








{ 15 comments… read them below or add one }
whats with the beehive tho?
Yeah, they went a little OTT with the skyhigh bun…still looks good in the photoshoot though. If someone were to wear that in real life im sure i would snigger !
i love the look so understated and wearable…and frankly i think dusky skin tone looks most beautiful ….
@ss&g – I agree, i am dusky myself and have no intentions of appearing any shade lighter or fairer. I love the skin Im in, but i also dont understand why people are creating such a controversy about how she is made to look fairer in this campaign. its a creative shoot after all!
Well, I'm on the ''ghostly'' white side naturally and personally don't like to bronze up.
But this is one heck of a gorgeous lady.
Paleness just goes with the story, don't see how people can find it racist.
@Gone2RehabBRB- I dont get it either. The same gorgeous lady was portrayed 2 shades darker in a recent movie. Didnt see anybody at that time stand up in arms against that
I agree with you.. I am personally a little tired of this entire "How dare you aspire to be fair?" business.. If Ash decides to take on a darker skin tone for another photo shoot/film tomo – should all the fair ppl get offended & scream Bloody Murder?
People shd be comfortable in their skin color, & they also need to grow up & realize that skin color is a personal preference.
If a slightly fairer skin tone makes someone happy – who are we to sit in judgement & say this is wrong.. It is their life, their skin. I think it is high time we learnt to be ok, not just in the skin we are in, but also be ok with the skin others are in.
It is a truly senseless controversy.
I think this controversy is nonsense…
I think she looks stunning on the pictures and that's what matters!
Confessions of a Beautyholic
shes lookin fab with that makeup..tho i hate ash…bt shes lookin nice here…
i love mickey contractor's work..
She's so beautiful, obviously she'll be on elle mag.
I have to say that i have a different opinion about the whole thing.I dont live in India and returned after 1.5 years.The first thing i noticed besides the crappy shows on indian tv is that almost all adverts have a porcelain face model ranting in hindi.im was so amused to find that our nation's obsession with white skin has gone even higher.i wanted to believe that i was wrong but more channels i browsed more surprised i became.i feel a geeta basra or chitrangada singh more beautiful than a katrina kaif.we indians are naturally gifted with exotic skintone and perfect face symmetry.we have most ethereal looks and we should keep it that way
@Shweta
I dont think the white skin obsession has gone higher. Til ten yrs back, you wouldnt have a chitrangada singh or rani mukherjee reaching the level of fame they have..
Also, india is made up of widely different skintones…ranging from the aiswaryas and kareenas to the chitrangadas and they are both equally gorgeous. I dont think dusky is mor gorgeous or fair is more gorgeous. They have their own appeal…
I guess ur right.in the other side of the world u have almost everyone trying end number of things to get perfect tan and here we have people trying to get white skintone.i was jst stating my choice that is defined indian features and brown skin
@Shweta – Mine too actually
killa looks